Ask An ECE

Men in Daycare

How many of you work with a man in the child care field or have a male child care provider at your child's centre? How do you feel about men in the child care field?

I took my Early Childhood Education Diploma both through Seneca College and Loyalist College. Out of all the courses I took to get my diploma, I had only one male in any of my classes. This student was fantastic. He had a real love for children, a willingness to learn, his projects were fantastic and creative. He would have been great addition to any daycare centre.

He did however have one problem...there was not one child care centre in our area that would allow him to do his field placement in their establishment. Without field placements he could not graduate. He was very discouraged, as you could imagine. He had taken the course after his nephews were born. This student had discovered he had a talent with young children and he really enjoyed spending time with them. I ended up leaving the school before I found out if he was ever allowed to graduate and I always hoped our paths would cross again somewhere in our field.

Today, as a supervisor, I would hire him in an instant based on his talent and passion for the job, however I also have to think of the parent's in my centre. How would they react to a male diapering and toilet training their children? Sadly, there is a stigma attached to men in child care. I have had the pleasure of working with only two men in the child care field over the span of six years, and both were in school-age programs where there is no diapering or toileting involved.

Perhaps this is why these men were more widely accepted. Although I must admit, there was more then one odd glance or derogatory comment made by parents about his choice of profession.

From these two experiences, I have come to realize the benefits of male staff in a child care centre:

  • They work twice as hard to prove they are capable of handling the job.
  • They have a natural ability with the older boys who are usually embarrassed to be attending daycare in the first place.
  • They provide different styles of teaching, behaviour modification and life experiences which only improves the program.
  • A well rounded childcare team is more representative of real life situations.
  • They provide a strong male role model for the children in the centre.
  • Men in the child care field help break the stereotype that child care as women's work.

Men make great parents, why not great child care workers too?

I agree - to me it is ridiculous in this day & age that anyone, regardless of their sex, would be treated this way in the workplace.

As parents we need to be mindful of how our actions are being viewed by our children - if they see or hear a parent being derogatory about one of their care givers, male or female, what are we teaching them?

I worked with a male in childcare and I have to say that he is one of the most fantastic people I have ever worked with.
Not only as a co worker but as a great childcare provider!
He was the school age teacher and did a fab job at it.
Some of the new parents were very concerned about him at first but as they got to know him, they found him to be great!
Never judge a book by its cover right?
More men should have equal opportunity in childcare with out people looking down upon them wondering if they are gay or pediphiles.

As a parent, I have to say I'm finding myself in this situation right now...and it is a struggle. There is a male daycare provider in my daughter's daycare. He is not her teacher, however the last couple of days my daughter has been brought into his classroom with him in the afternoon, because she is one of the later children to go home.It's my understanding, it is just the two of them. She is three. I don't have a problem with a male daycare provider, however I'm extremely uncomfortable having her with him alone. I don't know him. I don't allow her to be alone with any man, but her father so why would I be comfortable with her being with a stranger? I applaud his career choice and I'm sure he's good at what he does, but I'm a parent and it is my job to protect. I know that I'm not uncomfortable with her being alone with a female teacher and this is a double standard,but I also know that statistics show far more men in daycare provider situations molest than women. What is a parent to do? It's a little much to ask a parent to take a "wait and see" approach with something like this. I'd appreciate any advice, because I do feel bad that I'm concerned simply because he's a man.